Skipping $2m EBITDA Deals ("The Messy Middle")
Dan Tamkin of Resurgent Capital Partners shares his barbell strategy for lower-middle market PE deals, avoiding the "messy middle" to maximize returns.
Dan Tamkin, based in California and co-founder of Resurgent Capital Partners, is an operator, technologist, and turnaround investor, in that order. After a career revolving around tech turnarounds and challenged VC portcos, he has found the lower-middle market to be a better channel for value creation, especially when done via the deal-by-deal model of independent sponsorship.
Resurgent began in 2017 and now has a portfolio of 6 platforms, split 3 vs. 3 between larger deals that required external equity and smaller companies they could buy outright. They follow a barbell strategy: concentrate on very small deals (~$0.5m EBITDA) that they can control and on larger deals ($5m+ EBITDA) where the upside is meaningful, while avoiding the middle, while skipping the $2-4m EBITDA range. Their underwriting targets an "acceptable return" by keeping stable and/or fixing 1–2 core issues, then views "explosive return" as a potential that can materialy if one or more growth levers are realized.
They built Resurgent through bootstrapping. Dan had a consulting turnaround job that generated revenue which seeded Resurgent. His partner, Bryce, used that runway to source deals, travel, and acquire a small cash-flowing asset. This early holding created a track record and stable income.
Dan warns repeatedly about the $2m EBITDA case study, which he calls "the messy middle." Here's his math: Buy at 5x ($10m EV), double EBITDA to $4m over 5 years, and exit at 5x again ($20m EV). After 20 percent carry, fees, and taxes, the sponsor duo might net only ~$500k per partner for years of work.
He contrasts the lower-middle market PE with venture capital. In VC, boards are composed of fund investors who have different fund timeline, portfolio pressures, and motivations, all of which skews and delays decision-making. The lower-middle market offers a dynamic with stable businesses under clear ownership, a couple of discrete, endogenous* fixable problems, and achievable value creation without relying on optimism about market dominance.
More recent episodes
How to Build an Investor Database of 4,000 HNWIs
Jay Fuquay of Trinity Investors shares how they built a 4,000-person HNWI database and what traits define top-performing independent sponsors.
How to Build an Indy Sponsor Team Before Chasing Deals
Edward Crawford of Coltala Holdings shares how he raised capital, built a real team, and applied KPI-driven systems before sourcing deals as an indie sponsor.
From Searcher to Independent Sponsor to $225m Fund
Alex de Pfyffer and Ross Porter of Heritage Holdings reveal how they grew from searchers to sponsors to fund managers, achieving 99% IRR across 6 platforms.